Start with the phase that serves the goal you care about right now, and let your training experience break the tie. If you're new to lifting or coming back after a long break, you often don't have to choose yet: eating near maintenance with plenty of protein while you train can build muscle and lose fat over the same stretch. If you've trained steadily for a while and want to lose fat before a long muscle-building phase, cut first. If you're comfortable with where you are and strength or size is the goal, bulk first, with a small surplus.

Last updated: November 2026

Everyone knows the definitions. The order is where people get stuck.

A cut means eating below maintenance (the calories that keep your weight steady) to lose fat. A bulk means eating above it to support muscle gain. Nobody needs that explained twice.

What gets missed is that "which first?" is rarely a physiology question. It's a question about which phase you can actually hold long enough to learn something from it. A cut you quit in week three teaches you nothing. Neither does a bulk that turns into eating whatever's around. If a past cut or bulk fizzled out, that's why, and it's not because you lacked willpower.

So the better question is: which phase fits your goal, your training history and the next few months of your life?

Three starting points

Where you areUsually start withWhy
New to lifting, or back after a long breakMaintenance with high protein (a "recomp")Newer lifters can often gain muscle and lose fat together
Trained for a while, want to lose fat firstA cutYou start the long muscle-building phase from a place you're happy with
Trained for a while, happy with your current body fatA lean bulkA small surplus supports strength and size with less fat gain than a big one
Not sureA few weeks at maintenance, loggingYou'll find your real maintenance number before committing either way

Recomp, short for body recomposition, just means losing fat and building muscle over the same period. A 2020 review in the Strength and Conditioning Journal (Barakat and colleagues) found it happens in trained lifters too, not only beginners. It's slower and asks more of the details, but it's a real option, not a consolation prize.

When cutting first makes sense

The strongest argument for cutting first is practical, not metabolic. A muscle-building phase works best when you can run it for a long time. If you'd rather lose some fat first, starting a bulk while you're unhappy with how you feel makes it more likely you'll abandon it early.

You'll also hear an older argument: start a bulk leaner and more of what you gain will be muscle. The research behind that is mixed, so we wouldn't build a plan around it. Choose the cut because it's what you want, not because of a partitioning theory.

When bulking first makes sense

If strength is the goal and you're content with your body fat, there's little reason to diet first. Eating in a deficit can make hard sessions tougher to recover from, and that's a poor trade when performance is the point.

Bulk first, too, if you've just come off a long diet. Spending more time eating less is usually the wrong next step after a long stretch of it.

"Lean bulk" is the version worth running. A big surplus tends to add fat faster without adding muscle much faster, so the extra food buys you very little.

Size the phase before you start

Here's our opinion: most people pick a phase and skip the sizing, then judge it by a single weigh-in. Set a rate, a start and an end before you change anything.

For a cut, an evidence review on contest preparation (Helms and colleagues, Journal of the International Society of Sports Nutrition, 2014) suggests losing about 0.5 to 1 percent of body weight a week to help hold on to muscle. For a lean bulk, a 2019 review on off-season nutrition (Iraki and colleagues, in Sports) suggests gaining about 0.25 to 0.5 percent a week. These are planning ranges, not promises. Bodies don't follow the spreadsheet week to week.

Protein matters in both phases. The ISSN's 2017 position stand (Jäger and colleagues) puts people who exercise at 1.4 to 2.0 grams per kilogram of body weight a day, and a 2018 meta-analysis in the British Journal of Sports Medicine (Morton and colleagues) found the benefit for muscle gain leveled off around 1.6 g/kg on average.

To find the maintenance number all of this hangs on, the TDEE Calculator for Cutting and Bulking post walks through how to check a calculator's estimate against your own logs.

Signs it's time to switch

You don't need a fixed calendar, but you do need exit rules. Consider ending a cut when you've reached the goal you set, when your lifts have slid for several weeks in a row, or when logging has quietly fallen apart. Consider ending a bulk when you've reached your goal or when fat gain is running well ahead of your planned rate.

Between phases, a few weeks at maintenance is worth it. It gives your appetite, your training and your log a chance to settle before the next push.

Where AllStrong fits

AllStrong won't pick the phase for you. There's no nutrition setting for cutting, bulking or recomp, and the coach can't set your targets. That decision is yours, and the app's job is to show you how it's going.

Setting the number. The free Energy Balance screen shows your estimated maintenance alongside a mild surplus (250 calories over), a mild deficit (250 under) and a moderate deficit (500 under). You set the daily calorie target you want under Profile, then Nutrition Targets. Once you have at least 14 days of weigh-ins and 14 days of food logs within four weeks, the screen also refines the estimate from your real intake and weight trend. It doesn't change your target on its own, so when that estimate moves, update your calories yourself.

Logging. You type or say what you ate in the chat, and a progress bar fills against your target as you go. Each logged workout adds 60% of its estimated calories to that day's target (if your watch reports active calories, the app uses those instead), while your base target stays where you set it. The free plan includes 5 chat messages a day and Premium includes 10, and every message counts, including the ones that log something.

Watching strength. Workout tracking records personal records, including your heaviest lift in the 1, 2-3, 4-5 and 6-10 rep ranges, and you can ask the coach about them. On a cut, holding those numbers is one of the better signs your rate isn't too aggressive.

Body composition. If you get scanned on an InBody, DEXA or BIA machine, Premium's Body Composition Scans reads the printout or a screenshot, and Trends shows your latest scan with a line across recent ones. Our body composition scan app guide explains what it does and doesn't do, and body composition scan near me covers finding a scanner. Premium isn't sold on its own yet; it comes with a membership at a gym that runs AllStrong. Gym owners can see the platform side on our gym management software page.

Fair warning: none of these numbers are right for everyone. AllStrong doesn't show calorie targets or the Energy Balance screen to anyone under 18. If you're under 18, pregnant, managing a condition or medication that affects weight, or have a history of disordered eating, a doctor or registered dietitian should set your plan.

FAQ

Should I cut or bulk first as a beginner?

Often neither. People new to lifting, or returning after a long break, can frequently build muscle and lose fat at the same time by eating near maintenance with plenty of protein while training consistently. That's called body recomposition. Once that progress slows, pick a cut or a bulk based on which goal matters more to you.

How do I decide between cutting and bulking?

Start with your goal, then your training history. If you want to lose fat before a long muscle-building phase, cut first. If you're comfortable with your current body fat and want strength or size, run a lean bulk with a small surplus. If you're unsure, spend a few weeks at maintenance while logging food and weight before committing to either.

How fast should I lose or gain weight?

Research reviews give planning ranges. For a cut, Helms and colleagues (2014) suggest about 0.5 to 1 percent of body weight a week to help keep muscle. For a lean bulk, Iraki and colleagues (2019) suggest about 0.25 to 0.5 percent a week. Treat them as targets to steer by, not guarantees, and judge progress on weekly averages.

Does AllStrong have a cutting or bulking mode?

No. AllStrong has no nutrition setting for cutting, bulking or recomp, and its coach can't set your targets. The free Energy Balance screen shows your estimated maintenance alongside a 250-calorie surplus and a 250- or 500-calorie deficit, and you set your own daily target under Profile, then Nutrition Targets. Logging then shows your progress against it.